What is the difference between Ethernet and Industrial Ethernet?
03 August 2018
Industrial Ethernet systems must be more robust than office Ethernet – but why and in what ways? While similar, both Ethernet and Industrial Ethernet offer different characteristics and benefits. This piece explains what the two terms are – and how they differ...
For the digital issue of this piece, please visit this link – or click here to register for EPDT's magazine.
Ethernet was first developed in the 1970s, and later standardised as IEEE 802.3. Ethernet is the group of local area network (LAN) products and protocols covered by IEEE 802.3: a group of Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) standards that define the physical layer and data link layer of a wired Ethernet media access control. These standards also describe the rules for configuring an Ethernet network and how the elements of the network work with one another.
Ethernet allows computers to connect over a single network – without it, communication between devices in today’s modern world would not be possible. Ethernet is the global standard for a system of wires and cables to conjoin multiple computers, devices, and other machines, over an organisation’s single network, which enables all of these devices to communicate with one another.
Ethernet began as a single cable, which made it possible for multiple devices to be connected on one network. Now, an Ethernet network can be expanded to new devices as needed. Ethernet is now the most popular and widely used network technology in the world.
How Ethernet works
When using Ethernet, streams of data are separated into shorter pieces, or frames – each containing specific information, such as the source and destination of the data. Such data is necessary in order for the network to accept and send data as needed.
Other terminology of Ethernet technology includes:
- Medium – In modern Ethernet technology, a medium is a twisted pair or fiber optic cabling that Ethernet devices connect to provide a path for the data to travel on.
- Segment – A single shared medium.
- Node – Devices that attach to a segment.
Standard Ethernet is able to send data at speeds of 10 Mbps to 100 Mbps. Gigabit Ethernet is a term used under the IEEE 802.3 standard to describe Ethernet speeds that travel at a rate of 1 Gbps. Gigabit Ethernet was first typically used for backbone network transport and for high performance or high capacity servers.
However, over time, desktop connections and PCs have also been able to support it.
What is Industrial Ethernet?
Industrial Ethernet is just as it sounds: Ethernet applied to an industrial setting, which often requires more rugged connectors, cables, and – most importantly – better determinism. In order to achieve better determinism, Industrial Ethernet uses specialised protocols in conjunction with Ethernet. The more popular Industrial Ethernet protocols are PROFINET, EtherNet/IP, EtherCAT, SERCOS III and POWERLINK.
With Industrial Ethernet, data transmission rates range from 10 Mbps to 1 Gbps. However, 100 Mbps is the most popular speed used in Industrial Ethernet applications.
How it works
Industrial Ethernet protocols, such as PROFINET and EtherCAT, modify standard Ethernet in a way that ensures specific manufacturing data is, not only correctly sent and received, but also sent and received on time – when the data is needed to perform a specific operation.
Figure 1. This advanced technology is needed in industrial settings to ensure specific
manufacturing data is correctly sent and received. Considering an example of a
bottle filling plant, Industrial Ethernet automation technology is able to send filling
data over the network to ensure the bottles are being filled as intended.
In Figure 1 above, for example, a bottle filling plant using Industrial Ethernet automation technology is able to send filling data over the network to ensure the bottles are being filled as intended. When a bottle is full, a stop filling command will be sent over the network.
Such a message would not be as crucial in an office setting. If a webpage is lost, a user just hits the refresh button. In the factory, however, a little problem could turn into a disaster: the company cannot take the time for someone to notice the error and manually press a button. The Industrial Ethernet automation network, however, can sense an error in the bottling process and automatically stop a process – preventing wasted time, product and money.
Other differences between Ethernet and Industrial Ethernet
Office Ethernet is designed for a base level of use, while Industrial Ethernet can be considered for multiple levels and applied to more heavy duty environments. Industrial Ethernet is better suited to handle factory noise, factory process needs and harsher environments (see Figure 2 below) – and is able to respond better to data collisions at the plant floor.
Figure 2. Industrial Ethernet requires additional considerations not seen in Ethernet
systems used in an office. Manufacturing equipment on plant floors is exposed to
different temperatures, vibrations and other potentially disturbing noise
Cables and connectors may also differ in Industrial Ethernet technology. For example, connectors used in an industrial setting may not be the basic snap-in lock mechanisms.
Due to the rougher environment, heavier lock mechanisms are needed. Sealed connectors are also often needed in heavy duty applications.
Cabling, too, can differ between commercial or office Ethernet and Industrial Ethernet. Light duty industry cables may have a higher quality of jacketing than regular Ethernet cables. And, as expected, the jacket around the heavy duty cables, and the metal used, also increases in quality to make them more durable.
Determinism is an important factor when defining Industrial Ethernet and separating it from Ethernet. Standard Ethernet is not deterministic on its own, but industrial environments require determinism. They need packets of data to be sent and received at specific times, and they need a guarantee that data will be delivered each and every time.
This is because a loss of data or a delay of data between equipment in an industrial setting can end in disaster – such as a major flaw in the production process, for instance. This real time information transfer is often a major deciding factor for a company when it comes to choosing what type of Ethernet solution to deploy. Fundamentally, therefore, companies will need to assess their specific needs – and determine what Ethernet solution is best for their organisation.
Contact Details and Archive...